Central Gardens Historic District Roughly bounded by Rembert St., York, Cleveland and Eastmoreland Aves..Home prices in the Central Gardens district average $150k to over a million built in the early 1900's there are many new houses being built. The average price for homes on the market in the Central Gardens area is near $350,000. The average price of homes sold in the past year is slightly over $280,000. The average square footage is near 2400 with the cost per square foot from $122 but could go to over $150.